Henry Roy Real Estate, Ascend Realty, Rapid City South Dakota
Relocation

Compare Black Hills Communities

25 towns and unincorporated communities. Pick two to four and the full table appears underneath. Commutes are driving times to the Ellsworth main gate and downtown Rapid City. Median sold prices, where we have them, come from the MLS over the trailing twelve months with the source, window and sale count printed under each figure. Typical price bands are practical search ranges, not medians, and are labelled separately.

Narrow it

3 of 25 communities

Price filters only consider communities with a published trailing twelve month median, so towns without one do not appear in a price filter.

Browse

The five facts that decide a shortlist

Rapid City and the Ellsworth corridor

Everything within about twenty five minutes of downtown Rapid City or the Ellsworth main gate, where most of the newer inventory, the shortest commutes and the jurisdiction questions about city versus county service are.

  • Typical price
    $340k to $400kMedian sold $367,000. Black Hills MLS, single family, trailing 12 months, as of August 2026. 235 closed sales.
    To Ellsworth AFB
    9 min, 2.3 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    To downtown Rapid City
    19 min, 10.9 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    Utility pattern
    City water and sewer inside the limits
    School district
    Douglas School District 51-1Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
  • Typical price
    $300k to $450kMedian sold $349,950. Black Hills MLS, single family, trailing 12 months, as of August 2026. 706 closed sales.
    To Ellsworth AFB
    24 min, 13.8 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    To downtown Rapid City
    5 min, 1.5 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    Utility pattern
    City water and sewer inside the limits
    School district
    Rapid City Area Schools 51-4Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
    4 is the most that fits. Drop one first.Guide
  • Typical price
    About $350,000 average sold, 274 sales over 12 monthsAverage sold $349,971. Black Hills MLS, single family, 12 months through August 2026, as of August 2026. 274 closed sales.
    To Ellsworth AFB
    22 min, 10.4 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    To downtown Rapid City
    11 min, 5.2 miDriving time and distance, off peak.
    Utility pattern
    Utility service varies by address. Rapid Valley Sanitary District serves portions of the area, while properties outside district service may use private wells and septic systems.
    School district
    Mostly Rapid City Area School District 51-4, with portions in Douglas 51-1Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
    4 is the most that fits. Drop one first.Guide
What changes

Between Custer, Colonial Pine Hills, Buffalo Gap, Box Elder

The rows below are the ones where these do not read the same. Ordered as the table runs, not by importance.

Region
CusterCentral and Southern HillsColonial Pine HillsRapid City and the Ellsworth corridorBuffalo GapCentral and Southern HillsBox ElderRapid City and the Ellsworth corridor
County
CusterCuster CountyColonial Pine HillsPennington CountyBuffalo GapCuster CountyBox ElderPennington County
Jurisdiction
CusterNot recorded townwide in this guide. The address decides whether it is city or county ground.Colonial Pine HillsUnincorporated. There is no city government. Pennington County zones the lots, issues the permits and patrols the roads.Buffalo GapIncorporated town of Buffalo Gap, with Custer County outside the limits.Box ElderCity of Box Elder
Corridor
CusterUS-16Colonial Pine HillsUS 16 and Sheridan Lake RoadBuffalo GapSD 79Box ElderI-90
To downtown Rapid City
CusterAbout 50 to 60 minutesColonial Pine HillsRoughly 6 miles northeastBuffalo GapAbout 45 miles, roughly 56 minutesBox Elder19 min, 10.9 mi
To Ellsworth AFB
CusterAbout an hour and ten minutesColonial Pine HillsAbout 25 to 30 minutes, through or around Rapid CityBuffalo GapAbout 55 milesBox Elder9 min, 2.3 mi
Side by side

Custer, Colonial Pine Hills, Buffalo Gap, Box Elder

Rows marked as differing are the ones where these do not read alike. Rows without the mark sit on a quiet background because they say the same thing in every column.

Where it sits

Regiondiffers

Custer
Central and Southern Hills
Colonial Pine Hills
Rapid City and the Ellsworth corridor
Buffalo Gap
Central and Southern Hills
Box Elder
Rapid City and the Ellsworth corridor

Countydiffers

Custer
Custer County
Colonial Pine Hills
Pennington County
Buffalo Gap
Custer County
Box Elder
Pennington County

Jurisdictiondiffers

City versus county decides who provides service and who inspects the work.
Custer
Not recorded townwide in this guide. The address decides whether it is city or county ground.
Colonial Pine Hills
Unincorporated. There is no city government. Pennington County zones the lots, issues the permits and patrols the roads.
Buffalo Gap
Incorporated town of Buffalo Gap, with Custer County outside the limits.
Box Elder
City of Box Elder

Corridordiffers

Custer
US-16
Colonial Pine Hills
US 16 and Sheridan Lake Road
Buffalo Gap
SD 79
Box Elder
I-90

To downtown Rapid Citydiffers

Custer
About 50 to 60 minutesDriving time and distance, off peak.
Colonial Pine Hills
Roughly 6 miles northeastDistance only. Drive time is not measured for this community, so time it from the parcel.
Buffalo Gap
About 45 miles, roughly 56 minutesDriving time and distance, off peak.
Box Elder
19 min, 10.9 miDriving time and distance, off peak.

To Ellsworth AFBdiffers

Custer
About an hour and ten minutesDriving time and distance, off peak.
Colonial Pine Hills
About 25 to 30 minutes, through or around Rapid CityDriving time and distance, off peak.
Buffalo Gap
About 55 milesDistance only. Drive time is not measured for this community, so time it from the parcel.
Box Elder
9 min, 2.3 miDriving time and distance, off peak.

Winter drivingdiffers

Custer
Winter roads are a genuine planning factor at this distance, and on acreage you need to know who maintains yours.
Colonial Pine Hills
You are 900 feet above Rapid City on grades, and some subdivision roads are privately plowed. Snow tires are not a luxury item up here.
Buffalo Gap
Highway 79 is state maintained and is the connection to Hot Springs and Rapid City. Off it, this is open prairie with blowing snow.
Box Elder
I-90 is state maintained and the city clears the newer plats. Box Elder publishes no plow priority map, so ask a neighbor how the street clears after a real storm.

Housing and lots

Typical pricediffers

Custer
Median sold $627,000Black Hills MLS, single family, trailing 12 months, as of August 2026. 7 closed sales, small sample.
Colonial Pine Hills
About $683,000 average sold in the Sheridan Lake Road MLS area, 71 sales over 12 monthsAverage sold $682,615. Black Hills MLS, single family, 12 months through August 2026, as of August 2026. 71 closed sales.
Buffalo Gap
One single family sale shows in the Black Hills MLS over 24 months, at $80,000. One closing is a sample of one rather than a price level, so read it that way.
Box Elder
$340k to $400kMedian sold $367,000. Black Hills MLS, single family, trailing 12 months, as of August 2026. 235 closed sales.

Housing agediffers

Custer
Mixed ages. Older homes near the core, newer construction toward the edges.
Colonial Pine Hills
Platted over several decades, so 1970s cabins and current builds sit on the same road.
Buffalo Gap
An 1885 to 1939 historic core with an aging housing stock and about a fifth of units vacant.
Box Elder
Heavily new construction since the B-21 announcement

New constructiondiffers

Custer
Not recorded townwide in this guide. Check current permits with the city or county.
Colonial Pine Hills
Limited, mostly infill and small projects
Buffalo Gap
None underway
Box Elder
Active, with subdivisions still building

Acreagediffers

Custer
Acreage is common outside the city core, with wells and septic systems typical on many rural properties.
Colonial Pine Hills
Acreage parcels are common here
Buffalo Gap
Acreage parcels are common here
Box Elder
Not recorded townwide in this guide. The recorded plat carries the lot size.

Typical lotdiffers

Custer
Not recorded townwide in this guide. The recorded plat carries the lot dimensions.
Colonial Pine Hills
Large by Rapid City standards, from generous lots to several acres.
Buffalo Gap
A handful of historic townsite lots, with grassland and ranch ground around them.
Box Elder
Small city lots, about 0.15 to 0.18 acres in the newer plats

Covenants and HOAdiffers

Covenants are recorded per plat. The title commitment lists what binds the parcel.
Custer
Not recorded townwide in this guide. Read the recorded documents for the plat.
Colonial Pine Hills
Recorded covenants on some plats, none on others
Buffalo Gap
Few plats here carry recorded covenants
Box Elder
Not recorded townwide in this guide. Read the recorded documents for the plat.

Utilities and rules

Utility patterndiffers

Custer
Mixed, municipal service in town with well and septic outside it
Colonial Pine Hills
Mostly private well and septic
Buffalo Gap
Mixed, municipal service in town with well and septic outside it
Box Elder
City water and sewer inside the limits

Waterdiffers

Custer
Municipal water inside the limits, a private well or a district system outside them.Read off the townwide utility pattern in the guide. The service address controls, so confirm the provider before you write an offer.
Colonial Pine Hills
Depends entirely on the parcel. The Colonial Pine Hills Sanitary District serves roughly 430 connections. Several separate water associations serve other pockets, and the rest of the area is on private wells.
Buffalo Gap
Town of Buffalo Gap municipal water from a single well, serving about 93 connections. Rural parcels are on private wells.
Box Elder
City of Box Elder municipal

Sewerdiffers

Custer
City sewer inside the limits, private septic outside them.Read off the townwide utility pattern in the guide. The service address controls, so confirm the provider before you write an offer.
Colonial Pine Hills
Private on-site septic throughout, permitted by Pennington County. There is no municipal sewer and no lagoon serving the area.
Buffalo Gap
Not documented in the public record. There is no municipal wastewater project or discharge permit on file that I could find. Confirm with the town finance officer before assuming either town sewer or septic.
Box Elder
City of Box Elder municipal

Short term rentalsdiffers

Custer
Grandfathered permits are non transferable and expire when the property sells, and the rules flip at the city line.
Colonial Pine Hills
This is unincorporated county, so there is no municipal short-term rental ordinance. County zoning and subdivision covenants are what govern, and the covenants out here are often stricter than the county.
Buffalo Gap
This is hunting and grassland country rather than a tourism corridor. Demand is seasonal and specific.
Box Elder
A verify first town for rental plans, with one specific misconception the guide clears up.

Schools

School districtdiffers

Custer
Custer School District 16-1Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
Colonial Pine Hills
Rapid City Area School District 51-4Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
Buffalo Gap
Hot Springs School District 23-2, despite the town being in Custer CountyAssignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.
Box Elder
Douglas School District 51-1Assignment follows the official boundary for the address. Confirm with the district.

Daily errands

Groceriesdiffers

Custer
Lynn's Dakotamart is a full-service grocery store in town.
Colonial Pine Hills
Everything is in Rapid City, roughly fifteen minutes down US 16.
Buffalo Gap
Nothing full service in town. Hot Springs, about 14 miles south, is where errands happen.
Box Elder
Lynn's Dakotamart is a full-service grocery store in town.

Healthcarediffers

Custer
Monument Health Custer Hospital and clinic are in town.
Colonial Pine Hills
No clinic up here. Monument Health Rapid City Hospital and the Rapid City clinics are the answer.
Buffalo Gap
Fall River Health Services in Hot Springs, a 25 bed critical access hospital with a 24 hour emergency department and a rural health clinic, about 18 minutes away.
Box Elder
Monument Health Box Elder Clinic provides primary and urgent care in town. Hospital-level care is in Rapid City.

Recreationdiffers

Custer
Custer State Park at the door, including Sylvan Lake, the Needles Highway, the wildlife loop and the September buffalo roundup.
Colonial Pine Hills
Sheridan Lake, Pactola, the Mickelson Trail and the whole central Hills network start where the subdivisions end.
Buffalo Gap
Buffalo Gap National Grassland, hunting, rock collecting and OHV country, with the Cheyenne River nearby.
Box Elder
The Liberty Center, the city park and ballfield network, and the South Dakota Air and Space Museum are the in-town recreation. The Badlands are a day trip, not your neighborhood park.

Mapped subdivisions

Outlines on filediffers

Custer
No recorded subdivision outlines drawn for this community yet.
Colonial Pine Hills
No recorded subdivision outlines drawn for this community yet.
Buffalo Gap
No recorded subdivision outlines drawn for this community yet.
Box Elder
16 mapped outlines, 3 with a full guideReference outlines from county and city GIS, not surveys. The recorded plat controls.

The trade

Housing and patterndiffers

Custer
A county seat at a park entrance, with a replacement Monument Health hospital and acreage starting just past the city limits.
Colonial Pine Hills
Ponderosa pine subdivisions platted over decades, no two alike, on county rules six miles from the city.
Buffalo Gap
A nearly intact turn-of-the-century western streetscape on the National Register, mostly quiet, at the gate to the grassland.
Box Elder
A young city building its first downtown at Liberty Plaza on 110 acres, with roughly 800 residential units planned.

What you gaindiffers

Custer
You are inside the Hills with real acreage, Custer State Park at the door, and a new hospital in a town of about 1,900.
Colonial Pine Hills
Hills elevation, trees and lot size with a Rapid City commute and Rapid City schools.
Buffalo Gap
Eighteen minutes from the hospital in Hot Springs, with 600,000 acres of grassland out the door and one MLS closing in two years to price from.
Box Elder
The Ellsworth main gate is in town, 9 minutes from most addresses, on city water and sewer, with the region's newest housing pipeline.

What you give updiffers

Custer
Rapid City is 50 to 60 minutes and Ellsworth over an hour, grandfathered rental permits expire when a property sells, and outside the city limits there are no county building codes.
Colonial Pine Hills
Well or association water, septic on every parcel, private roads in places, and wildfire exposure that affects insurance.
Buffalo Gap
No school, no store and no services in town, an aging water system with an open compliance item, and an undocumented sewer situation.
Box Elder
Comparable sales run thin inside brand new subdivisions and builder incentives move the effective price without moving the list price. I-90 fills at shift change, and the flight line is close enough that you hear it.
Where this comes from

Commute figures are driving times off peak, from the community guide each card links to. Median sold prices come from the MLS, and each figure carries its own source, window and closing count, because Sturgis, Spearfish and the northern hills report through a different MLS than Rapid City. Under five closings there is no median, and the price row says so. Five to nine closings carries a small sample note. School districts follow the official boundary for the address, and the district office is the only place to confirm an assignment. Short term rental lines are summaries. Read the guide and the current ordinance before you count on rental income.

The filters use these definitions: under $400k is the MLS sold figure for the town, a median where one is published and otherwise the average sold, comes in under $400,000; close to ellsworth is 25 minutes or less to the Ellsworth main gate; close to rapid city is 20 minutes or less to downtown Rapid City; short commute is 15 minutes or less to either downtown Rapid City or the Ellsworth gate; new construction available is the guide establishes active or limited new construction; acreage available is acreage is common or present in the guide; city water and sewer is city water and sewer across the community; smaller market is fewer than 100 closed single family sales in the trailing twelve months; more rural is acreage is common, or water and sewer are not municipal throughout; established housing is the guide classifies the housing stock as established, meaning largely pre 2000; newer housing is the guide classifies a meaningful share of the housing stock as 2000s or later.

Every row here is a townwide summary and a single parcel can read differently. Buyer due diligence should include verifying water and sewer service, school assignment, recorded covenants and HOA obligations, rental rules, legal access, insurance availability and which jurisdiction inspects and permits the work, for the exact address. Confirm with the city or county, the utility or district, the school district office, the title company and your insurer as applicable.

Last updated August 2026

Contact

Want to talk through the tradeoffs?

Two towns can look identical in a table and feel nothing alike on a Tuesday night in February. Call or text and tell me which rows above are the ones you cannot live with, and we can work the list down from there.

Address Questions

Considering a home here?

Send the address and we can talk it through. The details that change from one property to the next are jurisdiction, water and sewer, the school the district assigns, covenants, road maintenance and the rest of what never shows up on a listing.

Or send a message from the contact page

ComparingCuster, Colonial Pine Hills, Buffalo Gap, Box Elder

Call HenryEmail